RedCircle's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Megaman X7 stragegy guide]

Well, at least you tried...

You did put in a little work. The facts were kinda interesting, if I could have read them in the short amount of time you showed them.

But, it was boring and badly done.

ViceFullbuster responds:

took me 6 hours too :(

[The Yellow Cheese]

Well, it was entertaining.

Graphics were not bad, and the music fit well.

The story could have been told much better, but as it is, it still explained everything alright.

You did take the extra time to make the 3Dness come through, and it worked. Good Job!

Still, nice work Carmel!

carmelhadinosaur responds:

Thanks! The sound could have been better if i wouldnt have recorded a recorded sounds (which have ofcourse been recorded XD).. I tried making bit different style of graphics this time.. hehe i guess it was better.. So, thanks again RedCircle, and good luck on.. umm stuff! (cheers)

[The Cartoon Parody!]

um.

Yeah, I really couldn't hear any voices. They were all like *muffle* *muffle*. I would recommend a Cotton Ball or Sock over your microphone next time you wanna do voices. Gets rid of that static sound.

As for the drawings, nice job!

I wish I could have understood what they were saying...

carmelhadinosaur responds:

Hehe i wish i had Sam Neil's voice so i could do voices in movies.. lol thats not a problem with the micro (hehe i know you didnt said it) thats my voice O_o
I will not use my voice anymore for words and sentences, only for sounds.. I tried making something like VG high, which is very original and inspiering (spelling?)..
Thanks for the 5 on that wierd movie RedCircle! :D

[Stupid Cop]

Uhhhhhhh......

What the hell just happened?

I am still scratching my head on that one.

What did it mean???????

(not your best Carmel...haha)

carmelhadinosaur responds:

Haha that was a dude pushing a dood and he fell on the cop's car, and.. thats about it :D
Lol haha i like the thing i did at the Again thingy.. lol thanks for reviewing =)

[South Park Theme]

Strangest...song...ever...

Well, that was coolness...

One thing though, I felt like the audio wasn't streamed, cause it got out of sync towards the end.

But, none-the-less, Beautifully done Carmel!

I am starting to get the notion that you like South Park...heh :)

Keep it up!

carmelhadinosaur responds:

Hehe yeah... i do like south park.. lol its pretty hard to guess :D
At first i didnt knew why wasnt it synced but now i know that its because i didnt choose the sync option for the sound..
Again, i never saw it here, so i made it... :)
Thanks RedCircle! ;)

[South Park 502 Part 1]

Excellent job.

That was a very hard project indeed. Getting everything to sync up must have been a pain.

I am only assuming that you imported the sounds...I mean, if can do those voices yourself, then OMFG...ha.

Anyway, excellent job, and maybe you can do a dialogue of your own, then put it to flash. Hell, you did most of the work already.

Excellent job sir, excellent job.

carmelhadinosaur responds:

Thanks again RedCircle!
I began it on 12 fps, and then changed it to 20 so it was a pain to change it all.. I even had to cut the sound and a HUGE scene into two..
Now (part 2) is so much better: animation, graphics, all!
Lol i wish i had a good voice for sounds so i can record myself and not getting the movie blammed because i used my voice.. :D
I am now also making a movie with other people's voices so it would be cooolol...
Thanks again!

[My Life Is Broken]

Song = Eagle : Vid = Par

Although an incredible song, I would say that this just didn't do the intentions/emotion of the song justice.

There were some parts that I found very meaningful: The sign language part and the "you want to act like you're someone" part.

But the other parts seemed to just act out the lyrics. Not that that's what you weren't trying to do, but it felt empty.

I, being a song writer, would be more harsh when it comes to things like this. I write lyrics as a way to get my emotions out. They will be interpreted differently by everyone else.

That's why, when I see this video, the emotions just don't cut through.

I would also like to add that Linkin Park's music video's don't do much for me either, so don't feel bad. If there is one thing I hate in this world, it has to be a band having a music video of them PLAYING!!! THAT'S WHAT A LIVE CONCERT IS FOR NUMNUTS!!!

Anyway, I digress. You put a <emphasis>shitload of time and energy in this movie. Hell, the song is over 3 minutes long, and you didn't stop.

So good job!

carmelhadinosaur responds:

First off all, thanks RedCircle for the 7!
I tried making it as similar to the lyrics more than the meaning of the song, so thats why its like that...
Linkin Park indeed could have made a better music video than just effects to live video like in in the end or so..
It was hard to make, but im pleased from it..
The flash symbol becoming a pic was annoying to make because i accidently deleted the pic so i had to search for to long in google to find it because i even forgot what terms did i used to search it..
Thanks for the review!

[Stupid idea]

Cute.

I am glad they were unsuccessful...

I really liked the way it flowed. Graphics were good, and the song was great!!!

Keep it up my friend!!

[Super Dodge Ball]

Ha, cool idea.

Neato that you used a whole bunch of ooooold games for this. Donkey Kong, RC Pro Am, Joust, Battletoads, Super Dodge Ball...all of which I remember very well.

Thanks for making that!!!

Very Enjoyable!

[Checkpoint... Done]

Ha....

That had to have been the worst level in the history of games. What a boring level. I hated it cause there were so many fucking monsters and it was dark...and I was soooo scared.

Anyway, thanks for reminding me that the Checkpoints were the best thing about that level.

Hated that blue flying fuck. I didn't understand what his purpose was, but damn...the humming he did was horrible.

You did a good thing, and I commend you for commenting on that.

Keep it up!!!